Catering Menu
Party Platters
-
Cheese Platter Start From $45
Vermont cheddar, muenster, swiss & pepper jack along with sliced pepperoni surrounding fresh grapes 12in $45 16in $65 18in $80
-
Imported Cheese Platter (Prices Vary)
Look through our extensive collection of imported meats and cheeses choose your desired combination and we’ll put it together
-
Antipasto Platter Start From $45
This crowd pleaser has every Italian specialty you can think of from imported prosciutto, soppressata, and provolone to fresh mozzarella, Genoa salami, and capicola, red roasted peppers, olives, pepperoncini and artichokes - too much to list!!! - served on a bed of spring mix 12in $45 16in $85 18in $105
-
Vegetable (Crudités) Platter Start From $30
Carrots, peppers, grape tomatoes, asparagus spears, broccoli florets, mushrooms, cucumbers, and celery surrounding your choice of our house dressings 12in $40 16in $60 18in $75
-
Fresh Fruit Platter Start From $35
Pineapple, cantaloupe, honeydew, watermelon, grapes and strawberries 12in $45.00 16in $65.00 18in $65.00
-
Shrimp Cocktail Platter (16-20ct) $23.99
Served on a bed of spring mix decorated with lemon, cocktail sauce included $23.99 per pound pre-cooked weight Larger shrimp available at market price
-
Buffalo Wing Platter $11.99
Choose from buffalo, barbeque, honey chipotle, or cajun. A great way to start the party, large and in charge, these wings come with celery and bleu cheese dressing $11.99 per pound
-
Stuffed Bread Platter $40
A variety of breads available or create your own, these are our personal family favorite! $40 per bread
-
Wrap Platter $10.95
Choose from any of our specialty wraps on our sandwich menu or our basic ham & cheese, roast beef, or turkey with lettuce and tomato. Platter includes mayo, mustard and choice of two homemade salads - coleslaw, potato, or macaroni $10.95 per person $9.95 without salads
-
Sub Sandwich Platter $10.95
A variety of subs cut into 6’s and arranged on a platter. Choose from our sub menu and includes mayo & oil/vinegar and choice of two homemade salads - coleslaw, potato, or macaroni $10.95 per person $9.95 without salads
-
Sloppy Joe Platter $11.95
Roast beef, turkey and swiss; baked ham, turkey, and swiss on a triple decker sandwich with coleslaw, tomato, and Russian dressing on rye bread. Choice of two homemade salads - coleslaw, potato, or macaroni $11.95 per person $10.95 without salads
-
Fresh Mozzarella Platter Start From $35
Sliced fresh mozzarella and ripe tomatoes topped with fresh basil, garlic, and olive oil 12in $35.00 16in $55.00 18in $65.00
-
Cold Cut Platter $11.95
Roast beef, turkey, ham, and Genoa salami with american, swiss, and provolone cheeses. Includes rye bread, kaiser rolls, pickles, mayo, mustard, and two homemade salads choice of coleslaw, potato, and macaroni salads $11.95 per person $10.95 without salads
Salads
-
Garden Salad Start From $30
Green peppers, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots and red onions over a bed of romaine lettuce half $30 full $55
-
Cobb Salad Start From $50
bacon, chicken, hard boiled eggs, red onion, tomato, avocado, shredded cheddar jack, black olives and crumbled bleu cheese served over romaine
half $50 full $80 -
Mandarin Salad Start From $45
Spring mix tossed with strawberries, blueberries, orange slices (clementines when available), crumbled bleu cheese and pine nuts half $45 full $70
-
Cranberry Almond Spinach Salad Start From $40
dried cranberries with toasted almonds and feta cheese tossed with baby spinach paired with poppy seed dressing on the side half $40 full $65
-
Grilled Chicken Caesar Start From $50
romaine lettuce tossed with fresh grated Parmigiano Reggiano cheese, homemade croutons, and grilled chicken served with classic Caesar dressing on the side half $50 full $80
-
Prime Coleslaw $5.99 lb.
Made in house $5.99 lb.
-
Prime Potato Salad $5.99 lb.
Made in house $5.99 lb.
-
Prime Macaroni Salad $5.99 lb.
Made in house $5.99 lb.
-
German Potato Salad $7.99 lb.
A classic red potato salad tossed in vinaigrette $7.99 lb.
-
Tri-color Pasta Salad $8.99 lb.
Spiral pasta with black olives, red roasted peppers, fresh grated Parmigiano Reggiano cheese, light garlic and artichoke hearts tossed in a white balsamic vinaigrette $8.99 lb.
-
Fresh Mozzarella $9.99 lb.
Fresh mozzarella, black olives, cherry tomatoes, garlic and basil tossed in olive oil $8.99 lb.
-
Cucumber Salad $8.99 lb.
Sliced cucumbers with red onions, dill & red peppers tossed in a white balsamic vinaigrette $8.99 lb.
-
2, 3, 4 & 6 Foot Subs Per Foot $24
Specialty subs add a minimum of $4 per foot. We use only the finest bread from Melone Brothers Bakery in Staten Island for these monsters!
Hors D'oeuvres
-
U-12 Shrimp Cocktail Each $3.00
-
Mini Sandwiches Each $3.50
-
Mini Crab Cakes Each $3.00
-
Chicken or Beef Satay Each $2.75
-
Filet Mignon on Toast Each $3.75
-
Scallops wrapped in Bacon Each $3.25
-
Shrimp wrapped in Prosciutto Each $3.25
-
Mini Quiches Each $1.50
-
Vegetable Spring Rolls Each $2
-
Stuffed Mushrooms with crabmeat Each $3
-
Stuffed Mushrooms with sausage and bacon Each $2.50
-
Puff Pastries filled with Raspberry compote and Brie Each $2.25
Entrees
Vegetable/Sides
-
Stuffed Long Hot Peppers with prosciutto and gorgonzola cheese Each $3.50
-
Eggplant Parmigiano Towers $8.99 lb.
-
Eggplant Rollatini Full $90 Half $55
-
Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Full $90 Half $55
-
String Beans Almondine Full $75 Half $45
-
Garlic Smashed Potatoes Full $85 Half $45
-
Grilled Vegetables full Full $75 Half $45
-
Prime’s Signature Vegetable Medley Full $80 Half $50
-
Prime’s Signature Roasted Red Potatoes Full $75 Half $45
-
Spanish Rice and Beans Full $65 Half $40
-
Stuffed Artichokes Each $7.99
-
Cornbread Stuffing with dried cranberries and walnuts Full $85 Half $50
-
Wild Mushroom and Sausage Stuffing Full $85 Half $50
-
Apple and Almond Stuffing Full $85 Half $50
Chicken
-
Franchese Full $95 Half $60
Egg battered sautéed with lemon and white wine sauce
-
Marsala Full $95 Half $60
Sautéed chicken breasts with sliced mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce
-
Parmigiano Full $95 Half $60
Breaded chicken cutlets topped with our homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella
-
Cordon Bleu Full $95 Half $60
Stuffed with ham and swiss with light honey mustard sauce
-
Rollatini Full $95 Half $60
Rolled w/ prosciutto & mozzarella w/ light brown mushroom sauce
-
Saltimbocca Full $95 Half $60
Topped with baby spinach, prosciutto, and mozzarella in a Madeira brown sauce
-
Murphy Full $95 Half $60
With sausage, potatoes, onions, and vinegar peppers (spice it up with hot sausage and cherry peppers)
-
BBQ Full $95 Half $60
Bone in chicken slow cooked smothered in sauce
-
Scarpariello Full $95 Half $60
Sautéed medallions tossed with pepperoncini peppers, artichoke hearts, sausage, and sun-dried tomatoes in a white wine sauce with fresh garlic
-
Concetta Full $95 Half $60
In light Romano sauce covered in broccoli rabe, red roasted peppers, and provolone cheese
-
Karen Full $95 Half $60
Sautéed chicken strips with red roasted peppers, artichoke hearts and black olives tossed in a garlic, butter and white wine sauce
Pasta
-
Baked Ziti Full $75 Half $50
-
Baked Macaroni and Cheese Full $75 Half $50
-
Stuffed Shells Full $75 Half $50
-
Manicotti Full $75 Half $50
-
Cavatelli and Broccoli Full $75 Half $50
-
Cheese Lasagna Full $75 Half $50
-
Vegetable Lasagna Full $95 Half $65
-
Lasagna Bolognese Full $90 Half $60
-
Aglio Olio Full $75 Half $50
-
Tortellini Alfredo Full $75 Half $50
-
Prime's Homemade Penne alla Vodka Full $80 Half $55
Meats
-
Barbeque Pulled Pork Butts Full $90 Half $60
Slow cooked and shredded with our sweet & smokey hickory sauce
-
Baby Back Ribs Full $110 Half $70
Slow cooked in a dry rub then covered in our barbeque sauce these babies fall right off the bone
-
Sausage and Peppers Full $85 Half $60
Sweet & hot Italian sausage tossed with red and green imported peppers in our homemade marinara sauce or garlic and olive oil
-
Nana's Meatballs Full $95 Half $60
Nana’s secret recipe, ask about our chicken meatballs but don’t tell Nana!
-
Pepper Steak Full $90 Half $55
Tender strips of sirloin sauteed with peppers & onions in our homemade teriyaki sauce served over rice
-
Kielbasa & Kraut Full $85 Half $55
Our Kielbasa comes from a little shop in north Jersey but that’s all we are gonna tell ya!
-
Roast Beef Full $120 Half $70
Our signature, store cooked roast beef served with demi-glace
-
Loin of Pork Full $75Half $45
Topped with demi-glace: seasoned full $75 half $45 stuffed full $90 half $50 Virginia
-
Style Ham Full $80 Half $50
Smoked ham glazed and sliced
-
Roasted Turkey Full $95 Half $60
Leave it to us to cook the perfect boneless breast for you served with gravy
-
Veal Cutlet Full $150 Half $90
Milk fed, top round veal from our butcher, only the best